The GTD forums at Davidco make for interesting reading, and excellent blogging material. One of the posts that I saw today went as follows:
I'm doing GTD, but I'm not getting things done
Here's what I'm not getting done: Make my business profitable.
Call it a goal, an open loop or whatever, but it's something I've resolved to get done a long time ago. But so far, it remains undone.
Believe me, I've brainstormed, did countless hours of project planning, and created hundreds of projects for it. I really want to make my business work, but so far I haven't been able to.
I used to think of GTD as a magic formula that gets anything done. But now I realized that if you don't actually have to ability to get it done, GTD won't help you. It's nice to muse over the slogan "Make it up. Make it happen." But if you don't actually have what it takes to make it happen, in the end, you'll have to do the renegotiating and lowering of your standards. It's still a legitimate GTD option, but it's not getting things done. It's just getting things out of your head and renegotiating them, so you'll feel good about what you couldn't get done.
Frankly, I still can't get myself to renegotiate my commitments and close down the business. I acknowledge there might still be more subtle things at the higher levels that I haven't captured yet. So I'm resolving to do just that. But whatever it is, I still wasn't able to make my business profitable. I wasn't able to get it done, not even with GTD.
Anyone tell me I'm wrong...
First off, this is a little like "
You've Got Mail" (sorry, OT, but one of my wife's favorite movies, seen too many times) in that we do not know what business or what market, so it is hard to offer meaningful advice. Be that as it may, this was one of the responses:
I can't speak to the detailed reasons why your business never became profitable, because I don't know them. I can speak on some level about what GTD does and what it doesn't do.
GTD is not a motivational system. It does a wonderful job of getting you to keep track of all the things you should be doing, but it doesn't actually help you do them. I had a burst of productivity when I adopted GTD, but that faded and I was soon left with nice neat lists of things that weren't getting done. That's what drove me into my interest in procrastination.
GTD is very much about defining and organizing work and not so much about what gets you personally motivated to do that work. GTD is workflow management, not psychology. No matter how much GTD you do, you're the one who has to get those things done.
I'm not trying to be harsh here, and I apologize to anyone who reads this message that way. I'm just pointing out that GTD is only one of the collection of techniques we all work out individually that helps us get things done.
I have to say that I disagree. My first response was to post this cartoon from
Gaping Void:
Seriously, though, most people only think that they are doing the best they can. GTD is a step toward truly achieving the goal of doing the best that you can. GTD does
"a wonderful job of getting you to keep track of all the things you should be doing, but it doesn't actually help you do them." Well, that is not exactly true. If you are keeping up with the things that need to get done, if you use the Natural Planning method of outlining projects, and if you invest the time to review your Next Actions and prepare yourself for actually doing these things, it follows that GTD does help you do them.
I find it to be highly motivational to get up in the morning and look over my notes and @Next Actions from the previous day and know exactly what I should do next. I am encouraged and energized by the prospect of checking off the little boxes on my
Weekly Review Checklist. And I go to bed every night secure in the knowledge that I didn't forget anything and that the sun will surely rise in the morning.
(Since beginning GTD, my wife and I have also faithfully kept to our exercise program, 5 days a week, and have each lost 10+ pounds in the past eight weeks, talk about motivation!).
I have a sneaking suspicion that the original poster is experiencing two problems that have nothing to do with GTD. The first is that they most likely do not "have their ladder against the right wall." In his book "
First Things First", Stephen Covey discusses the power of goals and the value of personal integrity. The key to making sure that your ladder is against the right wall is to use your educated conscience to "
do the right thing for the right reason in the right way" (
First Things First, pp. 138-145). The other problem is very likely that they are just not getting out on the street, knocking on doors and selling the product/service/widget. The "dot-com" glory days are long-gone, my friend. If you want a profitable business, you
must get out there and sell something!
As for the response that GTD is not motivation or psychology, well, this is flatly incorrect. There is so much power in knowing that you have everything at your fingertips, and you are able to choose with integrity
which task to work on,
when to do it, and
why. If that is not a reason to motivate you to get something done, what is?
"
Workflow Management" is a psychological tool of the highest order. So many people are tortured by the assortment of choices and deadlines that they experience each day. You can see it everywhere you go, in the faces of those rushing around, filled with sound and fury yet accomplishing nothing.
The reason that some may experience a "burst of productivity" only to have it fade is that, subconsciously, they realize that they are working furiously in the wrong direction. But they do not have the strength to change course, to apply their new power in a more appropriate (though unfamiliar) direction.
Getting Things Done allows you to marshall your own abilities, capture your aspirations, and coordinate your activities in a productive way. By starting at the bottom, organizing and separating the things that are important from the things that are merely urgent, you can accomplish all of your goals and create the high-quality life that you desire. Who would not be motivated by that?
Technorati Tags:
gtdgetting things done